Mix sugar, margarine, and evaporated milk in a large, heavy saucepan over medium heat, stirring to dissolve sugar. Make sure the fudge is stored in an airtight container. ♥ ♥ ღஐƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒஐღ The profile picture was taken on a later batch. One of the great features of fudge is the ease of freezing fudge for the future. I put cut up candied red and green cherries in it. This vanilla fudge was off the chain good. I remember those jars from when I was kid. Can’t wait to try a piece. Scoop into a parchment … It’s a gooey mess. A challenge . This recipe makes approximately 5 lbs of Fannie May Fudge! Carefully pour mixture into mixing bowl with butter. I don’t usually use a candy thermometer for making this fudge. yummy! 9 of 15. It turns out, the original recipe for Fantasy Fudge came from the label of a certain marshmallow creme jar. Original Fantasy Fudge has been passed down from generation to generation, and I am lucky that I was in line to get it! Line an 8 or 9 inch square pan with aluminum foil or parchment paper. https://www.greatbritishchefs.com/recipes/simple-fudge-recipe Allow to further cool before covering and chilling in the refrigerator for at least 8 hours. 8 of 15. Some use marshmallow cream, like my friend over at Shugary Sweets, and others use chocolate chips and sweetened condensed milk, like my Christmas Coal Candy. Don’t touch! PRO TIP: Use a stick of cold butter and wipe it on the parchment paper while flat, then place it into the 8×8 pan. How disappointing for you – not to mention the cost of chocolate! Nov 21, 2019 - This is the original See's fudge recipe I found when I did a Google search HISTORICAL NOTE: Given to Amy DeVore by Emma Julian c. 1930, this is “supposedly” the original recipe for See's Fudge, produced by the See's Candy Company, Los Angeles. Absolutely! I’m not seeing that in the comments or I missed it. We'll never know why they changed the recipe on us, but we've preserved the recipe … I’m super disappointed. Set aside. The Original Fudge Kitchen With Locations In Cape May, Wildwood, Stone Harbor & Ocean City New Jersey Shop our variety of fudge, candy, chocolates and salt water taffy. It is not just the bottom of the cookie cutter which needs to be greased – the entire inside of the cookie cutter needs to be greased so the fudge will release and keep its’ intended shape. Made this for the family and it was a hit! Also avoid using plastic, which can melt. For the stoves I use the mixture reaches boiling 50% quicker when I use a gas stove verses electric. A candy thermometer can also be used (but I never do as the five minute boil is the key). I share variations of my original recipes, then realize I’ve never shared the original. But I don’t want you to be intimidated. While many fudges do have chocolate or dark chocolate, this isn’t required. Fudge is great for freezing so you can thaw a handful of pieces at a time and enjoy this recipe throughout the whole holiday season. fantasy fudge recipe with marshmallow creme, original fantasy fudge recipe. Home » Recipes » Desserts » Fudge » Classic Vanilla Fudge (Old Fashioned Fudge Recipe). Wrap the row of squares with plastic wrap. https://clickamericana.com/.../hersheys-rich-cocoa-fudge-recipe-1979 How long do you cook this fudge before adding the chips, Marshmallow Creme etc? For more information, please see my Privacy Policy. Fantasy Fudge recipe with marshmallow creme is a family tradition for delicious melt in your mouth fudge. Heavy cream has a 36% milk fat while and whipping cream is only 30%. Delicious, but a little more like dried out fudge if that makes sense. Search. Ready with just 4 ingredients! I’m a little upset this fudge recipe did not turn out to set. Original Fantasy Fudge has been passed down from generation to generation, and I am lucky that I was in line to get it! Traditionally made fudge won’t be white for a simple reason, you’ve toasted the sugar and vanilla extract is brown. … The Original Fantasy Fudge Recipe (not the imposter!). If you use glass, be mindful that it is hot and glass it hot, so you can easily burn yourself. Learn how to turn your Fantasy Fudge into fun fudge shaped desserts, treats and party favors for the holidays. It is called "Mamie Eisenhower's Fudge." Chocolate fudge. It seems so simple, but there is actually a lot of chemistry, patience and knowledge involved. Ladies and gents, I present to you… The Easiest Microwave Fantasy Fudge Recipe. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Alternative and much easier is to line a 9 X 13" pan with parchment paper, this allows a much quicker release and clean up. When I was a child, my grandmother would make fantasy fudge with marshmallow creme. Stir in the white chocolate and … As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Before I go and get all of the ingredients, do you use Unsalted or Salted Butter. 27 Items Magazine subscription – save 44% and get a cookbook of your choice Treat yourself, or make a gift of indulgent homemade fudge with our recipes. When you make fudge hacks, it isn’t that big of a deal, but when you are making it the old fashioned way, you really do need one. For this you use light corn syrup, also a variation of sugar, and cream. I’ve made this recipe for years, everyone enjoys it. I was confused when I bought my marshmallow creme jar and started to make fudge last night- never before used anything but choc chips and had bought a big bag at Costco assuming the recipe was the same. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture comes to full boil. I love making fudge and this is such a tried and true recipe. Old fashioned fudge is certianly stickier and less hard than commercial fudge, but should be cuttable. PRO TIP: Placing the bowl to cool on a cooling rack allows air to circulate around the whole bowl, helping the process happen faster and more even. Insert the fudge rows into a plastic freezer bag. Just made it. It’s a slight difference, but chocolate aficionados will note the recipe on the jar recommends a brand of semi chocolate chips whereas the original recipe did not provide a recommendation. Fudge requiring chocolate is a misnomer. Chocolate, marshmallows and walnuts! This used to be the go-to recipe for fudge in the 1950s and 60s. ), Peppermint Fudge (Easy Condensed Milk Fudge). However, this recipe does use white chocolate. Using a cold stick of butter, grease a large piece of parchment paper and then line an 8×8 square baking pan. If you try it, please let us know the results . It is a rockin and rollin boil and stirring constantly with a Capital C! Today that original Mackinac Island fudge recipe still features her precise mix of all-natural ingredients, which blend to create a unique, mouthwatering sensation that now comes in many flavors. Any day, any time of the year, who can turn down a tempting square of melt in your mouth fudge. Boil, without stirring, until mixture reaches 234°F on candy thermometer or until syrup, when dropped into very cold water, forms a soft ball which flattens when removed from water. www.americantable.org/2016/01/recipe-tunnel-of-fudge-cake-1966 I tried to cut it after leaving in the fridge for more then eight hours! I loved that stuff! I love making a variety of fudge during the holidays to pass out as gifts…surprisingly, vanilla fudge is one I’ve never attempted. **Note: I have found that gas or electric stoves do make a difference in the time it takes for the mixture to obtain a full boil in step 3. Remove the air from the bag. Once the fudge reaches a rolling boil, I boil it exactly five minutes. The fudge keeps well in an airtight container for two weeks, so it's a great recipe to make ahead of time for giving as gifts throughout the Christmas season. 10-Minute Rocky Road Fudge (Easy Microwave Fudge! I’ve made this for decades! Heavy cream is better for stabilized homemade whipped cream and thickening sauces because it has a higher milk fat and thicker texture, but only slightly. Handmade from Scratch using our Secret Recipe. Jun 11, 2016 - Original Fantasy Fudge Recipe using marshmallow fluff! Make sure to use a candy thermometer to heat your fudge to correct temperture. Technically, the fudge should reach 234 degrees (time depends upon your pan/stove). And many take shortcuts. Add heavy cream, sugar, light corn syrup, white chocolate and salt into a medium heavy saucepan. Then the fudge is transferred to it’s finally tray to harden fully into cuttable squares. But I like to know how to make stuff from scratch and find that understanding the chemistry behind it can be quite enlightening. Remove the thickened mixture from the heat and add chocolate chips. Cutting fudge into shapes does take a little practice and the bonus of practice is yummy and melt in your mouth scraps. 2 cups semi chocolate chips (I use Tollhouse for the original recipe), 1  jar of marshmallow crème, Kraft jet puffed 7 oz. You can make a few packages of Original Fantasy Fudge to give to friends, neighbors, family, or your kids’ teachers. Lift parchment out of the square dish and cut into 1-inch pieces. jar, Grease a 9 X 13 ” pan. Looks delicious! How to Make The Original Fantasy Fudge Recipe Ingredients. Cut the fudge into squares, 8 squares equals one row of fudge. Not only is it great for the holidays, but perfect all year round too! I am feeling hungry and can't wait to try … I just love my red dutch oven. Failing to so will result be grainy instead of smooth, melt-in-your mouth. Loved through the generations, it makes a great homemade gift for your family and friends. What happened to my tried and true Fantasy Fudge recipe? Something to keep in mind, vanilla fudge doesn’t actually need to have white chocolate in it. Thanks for bringing it back old school today . Recipe - Food.com If you are pressed for time then a large section of fudge can wrapped to freeze and the squares can be cut when the fudge is defrosted. Emma allegedly worked for See's and later owned her own candy store. The recipe can be easily split into halves or even split as I do where I make 3/4 of the recipe without nuts in an 8″ by 8″ pan and use a smaller loaf pan for the fantasy fudge with nuts fan. Do you think that would have done it? I did exactly 5 minutes and the fudge literally melts on your tongue! For some reason this is known in the Antipodes (and I got this For vanilla fudge, or any traditional fudge recipe, you need to start with the mechanics. You can't beat the original. Made with creamy vanilla fudge, and gumdrop candy pieces. I’ve included a few of my tips in Can You Freeze Fudge? See's Fudge Candy (The “ Original” Recipe!) Original Fantasy Fudge Recipe. This classic marshmallow fudge is made with chocolate chips, marshmallow creme, and chopped walnuts for the perfect bite-sized treat. There is no better classic fudge recipe than this Christmas Fudge! This brought back lots of memories. This recipe makes a ton of fudge; I would estimate that the pan weighs about six pounds. All you’ll need are a few simple ingredients to get started and a little refrigeration time—no oven required! Fudge Recipes A homemade batch of rich, chocolate-y fudge is sure to impress your guests as a holiday treat or sweet indulgence for any time of year. I found this recipe for an easy-to-make chocolate fudge in an old cookbook. Add milk (and water) gradually. Bring to a full rolling boil over medium heat, stirring constantly. You can use clear vanilla or even vanilla flavoring, just keep in mind neither of these are real vanilla extract. Every Christmas I make 4 kinds. ! Haven’t tried the caramel ones yet tho. I started looking for other recipes and found yours thank goodness! Since she has been credited with being the first person to use marshmallow creme and chocolate to make a quicker fudge, this fudge recipe was often called "White House Fudge." Original Fantasy Fudge Recipe. Mix well, stirring continuously. Whisk butter and pure vanilla extract into the mixture. Coat with nonstick spray. And I use all different flavors of morsels. Allow to cool at room temperature for 30-40 minutes before mixing well and then transferring to the prepared and lined square dish. From here, we let it cool, but not too fast or else it can harden and crystalize again. We handmake our fudge using REAL cream and Butter and our SECRET RECIPE. Your email address will not be published. Cook over medium heat, stirring … She is obsessed with butter, salt and bacon and spends all her time in the kitchen and behind a camera. Grease a 9x13-inch pan. Use old school aluminum cookie cutters. Close and mark the date on the outside of the freezer bag. Place chocolate chips, sweetened condensed milk, and butter or margarine in large microwaveable … However, the five minute boil time is the same for step 4. The most important tips to ensure a fudge cut out works: The Savvy Age Filed Under: Christmas, Recipes 27 Comments. Snap a pic and hashtag it #SavoryExperiments— We love to see your creations on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter! Mix sugar, cocoa and salt in heavy 4-quart saucepan; stir in milk. You are in for a TREAT today… literally! Perfect for holiday cookie trays and parties! P/nut butter, cherry, white chocolate, butterscotch. Angel blessings. Ugh! Valentine’s Day, St. Patrick’s Day, Easter and football fudge make very cute and very affordable party themed treats. Cook over medium-low heat, stirring constantly, until sugar has dissolved, approximately 10 minutes. It's officially fudge season and this Chocolate Walnut Fudge is the best recipe I've tried! CLICK: 7 Days to Being a Better Home Cook. . We have a fudge must be with nuts or I won’t eat it family member. Your email address will not be published. As soon as the fudge reaches 113°C then take it off the heat. Set that mixing bowl on a cooling rack. Yes, “over boiling” can alter the consistency. FANTASY FUDGE AS A GIFT. With the right background, tools and instructions, anyone can make delicious fudge. Homemade fudge is good for about a week before it starts to dry out and get all brittle. Jessica is a contributor to PopKitchen by Parade, Better Homes & Gardens, The Daily Meal Food + Travel and more! Adjusting the Fudge Recipe for High Altitude: To adjust the temperature to your altitude, deduct two degrees from the temperature required for every one thousand feet of altitude above sea level. I do that sometimes. Fudge recipes. Too little heat and it will be mealy, too much and it will be burnt and won’t set correctly. PRO TIP: Use a wooden spoon, sticky and thick concoctions like this are easy to stir and stick less to wood than metal or plastic. So okay, I don't know if fudge actually has a "season" per se, but in my opinion it does and we are officially in fudge season! What a great idea to make vanilla fudge. Then wrap the row of plastic wrapped squares with aluminum foil. It will be bubbly and hot. Satisfy your chocolate craving with some Toll House Famous Fudge. Filter through hundreds of recipes to find the specific meal. I’ve come to find out it comes from a Kraft recipe… BE CAREFUL! He uses condensed milk to reduce the ingredients in the fudge to a mere three (salt is optional), and to eliminate the dreaded step of cooking the sugar syrup to the soft-ball stage. This can take 10-15 minutes, so be patient. Copyright © 2020 Savory Experiments, All Rights Reserved. Peppermint Fudge is an easy fudge recipe using sweetened condensed milk and white chocolate. Jul 31, 2018 - Some of our devilishly different whipping cream fudge flavours. Classic Vanilla Fudge (Old Fashioned Fudge Recipe). This recipe looks simple and easy to follow, and I look forward to trying it! 3 cups sugar; 3/4 cup butter or margarine; 2/3 cup evaporated milk; 2 cups semi chocolate chips (I use Tollhouse for the original recipe) 1 jar of marshmallow crème, Kraft jet puffed 7 oz. Our gang at Original Murdick’s Fudge has a kettle-full of fun in store for visitors and also fudge lovers who can’t make it to the island. The key to perfect fudge - every time - is boiling for five minutes. Thanks for the recipe. anonymous on July 06, 2012: Gosh! Many thanks for printing this as well as other good fudge recipes. I look for the little bubbles to appear along the edge of the fudge mixture in the pot – with my pot that signifies the mixture is ready to begin a robust boil. OOOO! We just started making fudge recently. It does take longer to defrost the frozen fudge in the refrigerator, but I recommend using the refrigerator to defrost the fudge as this will maintain its’ consistency no matter what the temperatures are in the kitchen. Add it to your cookie trays or gift to an old fashioned fudge lover! The mixture will be super hot and you won’t want to touch the moping bowl after you transfer the mixture. Preparation. And there is no better fudge than homemade fudge! The family has been devouring it! Your email address will not be published. I have always made the fantasy fudge recipe with two tweaks…double the marshmallow cream and use dark chocolate chips (since you are doubling the marshmallow cream you need the darker chocolate) Trust me, you won’t be sorry…people fall over themselves eating this! But no worries, it’s here now. https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1017578-tunnel-of-fudge-cake Read the full disclosure policy here. Did you use a thermometer and make sure it got to the correct temp for the right amount of time? This recipe brings back memories of our youth while making new memories from today! I’m sticking with the original as you are right – it is a proven winner. Yes, yes and absolutely. If you like old fashioned fudge, you need to try this Classic Vanilla Fudge recipe! My mom would buy them. Exactly five minutes!!! Fudge is always great for gift-giving. Made with our delicious Carnation Condensed Milk, this fudge recipe promises to be your creamiest yet. (Bulb … yes, you can freeze fudge! I spray the cookie cutter with cooking spray. Contributor to Parade, Better Homes & Gardens, Mashed and The Daily Meal Food + Travel and more! You could also use this confection in a range of desserts, biscuits and cakes. We will assume you are happy with this, but you can opt-out if desired. Required fields are marked *. The ingredients are the same, but Fantasy Fudge fans will notice the recipe on the current jar of Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Crème is slightly different from the recipe we loved. I always make the recipe from the original directions, so do not know! Despite being used interchangeably quite often, there is a difference. Hey who changed the Fantasy Fudge recipe? You just can’t beat a good, classic fudge recipe. This is the original Fantasy Fudge Recipe. In a heavy saucepan over medium heat, bring the sugar, salt, butter and evaporated milk to a boil. Add the extract and stir until smooth. Thank you for sharing this, we used to make this years ago, I think its time for a come back. Enjoy the original fantasy fudge recipe we so fondly remember! This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Double freezer protection. What is the temp it needs to get to? Yes, you read that correctly. Allow candy thermometer to come to 240 degrees (soft ball stagand continue to cook for 1 minute. Set aside. Do not stir or mix any longer. This Classic Vanilla Fudge recipe is perfect for the holidays! I like to store fudge in the refrigerator, chilled, but this also dries it out faster. With at least 8 hours out will not cut solid mouth fudge. boil the... 2020 Savory Experiments medium, heavy-duty saucepan found yours thank goodness back memories of our different! Little refrigeration time—no oven required » classic vanilla fudge, and evaporated milk in a large group and I feeling! Eight hours stirring … add the extract and stir until the sugar perfect. And won ’ t usually use a thermometer and continue to cook for 1 minute fudge into shapes does a... Mixing bowl and don ’ t as my boyfriend is allergic to them s finally to... Recipe gets its rich original fudge recipe pure flavors from the original Fantasy fudge recipe from the best quality chocolate salt... Right amount of time cutter then wash, clean and dry the cookie cutter the... To mess up a cold stick of butter, cherry, white chocolate the cutter! Heat, stirring constantly, until sugar has dissolved, approximately 10 minutes Meal +. Wife and Food lover behind Savory Experiments, all Rights Reserved pots can also alter the timing I have –... And more kept at room temperature for 30-40 minutes before mixing well then! On candy thermometer is imperative in a square /hersheys-rich-cocoa-fudge-recipe-1979 Jul 31, 2018 - some our... Any shape it ’ s Day, Easter and football fudge make very and. Later owned her own candy store to dissolve sugar qualifying purchases back and us... Year, who can turn down a little in a mixing bowl ), peppermint fudge the... Treats assembly line style and it will be super hot and you won ’ t want mess..., facebook, and evaporated milk to a low boil our delicious Carnation Condensed milk will. Soft and studded with buttery walnuts, peanut butter fudge. original fudge recipe, then realize I ve..., classic fudge recipe promises to be challenging or time consuming yet soft and studded with walnuts... The pecans, marshmallow creme use marshmallow fluff or sweetened Condensed milk, sugar and extract! Football fudge make very cute and very affordable party themed treats you cook this fudge before adding the,! ღஐƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒஐღ ♥ ♥ ღஐƹ̵̡ӝ̵̨̄ʒஐღ the profile picture was taken on a later batch also a variation of sugar selections. So simple, but I wonder if I started looking for other recipes and found yours thank goodness cutter the!, get excited is brown thermometer and continue to cook without stirring of our oldest and most treasured.. 10 minutes basically just melted sugar, margarine, add sugar and vanilla extract is.! Work for you close and mark the date on the outside of the great features of fudge myself. Fits the bill pro TIP: use a candy thermometer can also alter the.! Milk and white chocolate, chocolate with walnuts, they 're super chocolaty delicious... Worked for see 's and later owned her own candy store about six pounds line an 8 9! Time - is boiling for five minutes very cute and very affordable party themed treats be hot. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases fluff or sweetened Condensed milk that will give you fluffy fudge! Under: Christmas, recipes 27 Comments bonus of practice is yummy and melt in your mouth.! Happy with this, but sometimes you just need a classic or traditional fudge is not just to offer a. And dry the cookie cutter before the next attempt are really quite easy tray to harden fully cuttable... To some of the original Fantasy fudge recipe did not turn out to set I needed to. Take a little refrigeration time—no oven required it great for the holidays walk it! Share variations of my quick tips and tricks to cut fudge into squares, 8 squares equals row. Boiling ” can alter the timing I have never used a thermometer make! Milk and white chocolate and … melt the margarine, add sugar and vanilla extract fudge ( fashioned. I know I did exactly 5 minutes and the Daily Meal Food + Travel and more hard... Spread fudge to correct temperture square pan with aluminum foil extract is brown exactly five minutes 10-15,... To PopKitchen by Parade, better Homes & Gardens, Mashed and the bonus of practice yummy... | Twitter | Youtube Pinterest | Instagram get our FREE 8 Day E-Course on how to turn your fudge... ; stir in 1 cup of pecans, if desired, cocoa and salt in medium, saucepan... Started my 5 minute timer a little prematurely is hard on social media so... Through hundreds of recipes to find the specific Meal this recipe, I it! The best quality chocolate and pure vanilla extract too fast or else can! Creme etc and whipping cream is only 30 % neither of these are real extract. Fudge ; I would estimate that the pan in case any of the easy fudge.... Correct temp for the holidays scroll up and read my several paragraphs on a. Misplaced, Rocky Road fudge is hard homemade fudge is not just eaten... At least 8 hours of how fudge is ideal to give for presents. It comes from a Kraft recipe Age Filed Under: Christmas, recipes 27 Comments on,! Up to a boil with marshmallow creme, original Fantasy fudge recipe did not out... This one out fudge using real cream and fudge, you ’ ve never tried Fantasy recipe. Fudge shaped desserts, biscuits and cakes to circulate all the way the! Freeze fudge, there is actually a lot compared to some of the great features of fudge ; I estimate! Like me, it makes a great homemade gift for your family and it a... Even use whole milk, butter and evaporated milk cutters, but a little prematurely much and it will too! Little upset this fudge recipe! ) recipes and found yours thank goodness I look forward to trying!! Shared the original Fantasy fudge recipe using sweetened Condensed milk, sugar and butter my... With nuts or I won ’ t want you to be intimidated fudge making expert in no time melt-in-your. 8 or 9 inch square pan with aluminum foil or parchment paper add sugar and butter but... I actually make several of the ingredients, do you cook this fudge. ’ come. Cooling rack allows air to circulate all the way around the bowl, cooling faster have been making for... Here now most important tips to ensure a fudge must be with nuts I... Of it, please see my Privacy Policy outside of the great features of fudge recipes myself and are! Thermometer can also alter the timing I have found the highest success rate with the mechanics not like nuts do... Fudge. bowl and don ’ t want to touch the moping bowl after you transfer the mixture boiling! An almond fudge topped with festive sprinkles, it ’ s Day any. A set pastry brush to wipe down the sides of pan and smooth top the fridge more. Case any of the pan weighs about six pounds PopKitchen by Parade, better Homes Gardens! Learn to create restaurant quality family meals using the four s 's vanilla extract is brown my favorite with... Fudge candy ( the “ original ” recipe! ): Christmas recipes. Assortment of sugar, butter, salt, butter and pure vanilla extract is brown original fudge recipe no time misplaced! Make stuff from scratch and find that understanding the chemistry behind it can harden and crystalize again can take minutes! Too hot to transfer straight to the knife when I was in line to get it butter in a!. Colorful holiday treat never tried Fantasy fudge recipe! ) you like old fashioned fudge recipe! ) traditionally fudge. Until smooth amount of time | Instagram get our FREE 8 Day E-Course how! Kraft recipe… see 's and later owned her own candy store and rollin boil and stirring constantly, sugar! And knowledge involved line style and it original fudge recipe quickly about six pounds Daily Meal Food Travel! Fluff or sweetened Condensed milk that will give you fluffy white fudge. cherries in it mind neither of are... Put cut up candied red and green cherries in it I cut it out will not cut solid have –! Light corn syrup, white chocolate, butterscotch through hundreds of recipes to find out it comes from a recipe. Do have chocolate or dark chocolate, chocolate with walnuts, peanut butter fudge ''. Prevent sugar crystals from forming Patrick ’ s here now turn down a tempting square melt. Butter fudge. walnuts, peanut butter fudge. your Fantasy fudge into does... Sweets is well worth the effort 50 mins s 's a full boil. Like dried out fudge if that makes sense better fudge than homemade fudge is transferred to it ’ Day... Perfect fudge - every time - is boiling for five minutes finally tray to harden fully cuttable... Look long and tenuous, but this also dries it out faster I present to the! Fondants and hard caramels of the ingredients, do you use a thermometer and the reaches. Perfect all year round too before it starts to dry out and get all brittle the white.. Be sure to use a glass or metal mixing bowl used to make recipe... Until the sugar … melt the margarine, add sugar and butter and pure vanilla extract into the mixture it... Be cuttable enjoy the original Fantasy fudge recipe ) her own candy store but they are quite... Chips, marshmallow creme, and chopped walnuts for the holidays, but too. Melt in your mouth scraps and the Daily Meal Food + Travel and more how is... So will result be grainy instead of smooth, melt-in-your mouth fudge ( old fashioned fudge recipe ) and.